ruliorulio Open the app

Good to know · Guide

What does a short stock trade cost? Four routes compared from a euro account

As of: 22 September 2026

If you buy a stock for a few days and sell it again a few percent higher, you pay twice: on the way in and on the way out. Then there is the path of the money itself — to the broker and back again. With small amounts these costs decide whether anything of the gain is left. I worked it through for four providers, from the viewpoint of someone in Europe whose money is in euros: not just the single trade, but the whole journey.

Up front, so the interest is clear: I run rulio. rulio is not a broker but a tool that executes rules at a broker — currently Alpaca. That is why Alpaca is in the comparison, and rulio is counted with its own costs.

The whole bill

Deposit money, make short trades in a US stock, withdraw the money again. The account runs in euros. Four cases: €300 or €3,000 deposited, ten or 200 trades.

The amounts are the deposit. Every trade uses exactly that amount and is held for ten days; the price stays unchanged in the calculation. That way the result shows only what the route cost. In reality the account grows or shrinks as you trade. Costs charged as a percentage of the trade value then grow with it — the fixed amounts per order do not.

Green marks the cheapest route per case. Click a row to see the bill behind it.

RouteDeposit €300Deposit €3,000
10 trades200 trades10 trades200 trades
Alpaca (with rulio), money in euros€9.03€10.90€70.26€83.56
Deposited€300.00€300.00€3,000.00€3,000.00
Conversion to dollars: 1.5%, max. $40−€4.50−€4.50−€34.78−€34.78
US regulatory fees: about €0.01 or €0.07 per sale−€0.10−€2.00−€0.70−€14.00
Conversion back to euros: 1.5% of the remainder, max. $40−€4.43−€4.40−€34.78−€34.78
Total cost−€9.033.0%−€10.903.6%−€70.262.3%−€83.562.8%

Alpaca charges no order fee for US stocks. On a sale, mandatory US regulatory fees apply: about €0.01 on €300, about €0.07 on €3,000. The account runs in dollars. You convert once when you deposit and once when you withdraw, not on every trade.

Almost the entire sum arises on the money path, almost nothing from trading. That is why 200 trades cost hardly more than ten. On €3,000 the $40 cap applies; without it, it would be €45 each way.

Trading 212, Invest account€9.00€180.00€90.00€1,800.00
Deposited€300.00€300.00€3,000.00€3,000.00
Currency markup on every purchase: 0.15%−€4.50−€90.00−€45.00−€900.00
Currency markup on every sale: 0.15%−€4.50−€90.00−€45.00−€900.00
Total cost−€9.003.0%−€180.0060.0%−€90.003.0%−€1,800.0060.0%

Trading 212 charges no order fee in the Invest account, and deposits and withdrawals by bank transfer are free. Instead, 0.15% is added to the exchange rate on every purchase and every sale of a stock in a foreign currency. There and back that is 0.3% of the amount — on every trade anew.

The cost grows with the amount and with the number of trades. For a few trades this is the cheapest route, for many an expensive one.

Interactive Brokers, US exchange, tiered pricing€9.84€130.70€10.79€149.65
Deposited€300.00€300.00€3,000.00€3,000.00
Conversion to dollars: $2−€1.74−€1.74−€1.74−€1.74
Commission: $0.35 per order−€6.09−€121.74−€6.09−€121.74
Exchange and clearing fees: about $0.01 or $0.03 per order−€0.17−€3.48−€0.52−€10.43
US regulatory fees: about €0.01 or €0.07 per sale−€0.10−€2.00−€0.70−€14.00
Conversion back to euros: $2−€1.74−€1.74−€1.74−€1.74
Total cost−€9.843.3%−€130.7043.6%−€10.790.4%−€149.655.0%

Interactive Brokers works the other way round: a minimum fee per order and almost nothing percentage-based. On tiered pricing it is $0.0035 per share, at least $0.35 per order. On top come the fees of the exchange (around $0.003 per share) and of clearing ($0.0002 per share). The calculation assumes a stock around $336: one share on €300, ten on €3,000.

Depositing by SEPA is free, and so is one withdrawal a month. The amount hardly matters: €3,000 costs almost the same as €300. For a few trades with larger amounts this is the cheapest route.

Interactive Brokers, US exchange, fixed pricing€20.97€353.31€21.57€365.31
Deposited€300.00€300.00€3,000.00€3,000.00
Conversion to dollars: $2−€1.74−€1.74−€1.74−€1.74
Commission: $1 per order, exchange and clearing included−€17.39−€347.83−€17.39−€347.83
US regulatory fees: about €0.01 or €0.07 per sale−€0.10−€2.00−€0.70−€14.00
Conversion back to euros: $2−€1.74−€1.74−€1.74−€1.74
Total cost−€20.977.0%−€353.31117.8%−€21.570.7%−€365.3112.2%

On fixed pricing it is $0.005 per share, at least $1 per order. Exchange and clearing are included, regulatory fees come on top. For small share counts tiered pricing is cheaper; which one applies is a setting in the account.

Interactive Brokers, Xetra in euros, fixed pricing€60.00€1,200.00€60.00€1,200.00
Deposited€300.00€300.00€3,000.00€3,000.00
Commission: 0.05% per order, at least €3−€60.00−€1,200.00−€60.00−€1,200.00
Total cost−€60.0020.0%−€1,200.00400.0%−€60.002.0%−€1,200.0040.0%

Buying the stock on Xetra in euros saves the conversion to dollars. In return the minimum fee is higher: €3 per order on fixed pricing. For both amounts the minimum applies; 0.05% would be less. On tiered pricing it is at least €1.25 per order, plus the exchange's fees.

Xetra lists only the large US names, and their trading spread is wider there than on their home exchange. With 200 trades on €300, the fees come to four times the stake.

Capital.com (CFD without leverage, 1:1)€3.00€60.00€30.00€600.00
Deposited€300.00€300.00€3,000.00€3,000.00
Spread between buy and sell price: about 0.1% per trade−€3.00−€60.00−€30.00−€600.00
Total cost−€3.001.0%−€60.0020.0%−€30.001.0%−€600.0020.0%

Capital.com is a different product. What you trade there are CFDs — contracts on a stock's price, not the stock itself. There is no order fee, and deposits and withdrawals are free.

Set leverage to 1:1 and there is no overnight holding cost either: the provider does not charge it at 1:1, apart from a short list of exceptions (natural gas, US cocoa, VIX and currency pairs involving the Turkish lira). What remains is the spread — which makes this the cheapest route in the table over ten trades.

The spread depends on the stock: $0.30 per share for Apple, just under 0.1% at a price around $336; $0.10 for Zillow at a price around $30, a good 0.3% — then ten trades with €300 cost €9 instead of €3. On top comes a currency markup of 0.4% when the account runs in euros. It applies when profit or loss is converted, not to the stake; with an unchanged price it therefore stays out of the bill.

Cheap is not the same as equivalent. You do not own the stock, you have no voting rights, and the position is a contract with this one provider — if it fails, there is no security in a custody account of yours. Dividends are mirrored, not paid out. The provider itself states that 74–89% of retail accounts lose money trading CFDs.

Capital.com (CFD, leveraged)€9.60€192.00€96.00€1,920.00
Deposited€300.00€300.00€3,000.00€3,000.00
Spread between buy and sell price: about 0.1% per trade−€3.00−€60.00−€30.00−€600.00
Overnight holding cost: 10 nights at 0.022% per trade−€6.60−€132.00−€66.00−€1,320.00
Total cost−€9.603.2%−€192.0064.0%−€96.003.2%−€1,920.0064.0%

As soon as leverage is set, the overnight holding cost applies: 0.022% of the position value per night, a good 0.2% over ten nights. The calculation uses the same stake as everywhere else — leverage only changes how much money has to be put up, not the size of the position.

The same trade therefore costs more than three times as much as without leverage. If you do not need the leverage, do not leave it on.

What the table shows

The routes differ in WHERE the costs arise: on the money path or on every trade.

At Alpaca almost only the money path costs anything. At Trading 212 and Capital.com almost only the trade does, and as a percentage. Interactive Brokers sits in between: a cheap money path and a small fixed amount per order.

Every share has a gap between buy and sell price, on every route. For large stocks it is tiny, for small ones noticeable. It belongs to the market, not the broker, which is why it is not in the table.

Over ten trades, Capital.com without leverage is the cheapest at both amounts — only the spread is left. But that is a different product: you hold a contract on the price, not a share. If you actually want to own stock, compare the other rows with each other; on €300, Trading 212 and Alpaca are level, and on €3,000 Interactive Brokers on tiered pricing is ahead.

If you trade a lot you need a route without percentage costs per trade. With 200 trades on €3,000 the 0.3% markup per trade costs €1,800 and the CFD spread €600 — Alpaca comes to €84. On €3,000, Interactive Brokers on tiered pricing is the cheapest up to about 100 trades, after that Alpaca.

Alpaca is the route for many trades with money that stays there: you pay for the money path once, and after that trading costs almost nothing.

What this means for small amounts

One trade with €300 and a 7% gain brings €21 before costs. Ten such trades bring €210. The journey costs between €3 and €60 depending on the route — a seventieth of the gain at best, more than a quarter at worst.

On €3,000 the picture turns: the minimum fee no longer matters, the percentage markup does.

And rulio itself?

rulio costs nothing in this calculation. Building and running rules, prices, savings plans and trading through your own Alpaca account are part of the free basic tier, with up to three active rules. For the trades in the table, that is enough.

If you need more, Plus is €9.90 a month: 20 active rules, ten times the AI credits and the full list of buy candidates. The price is fixed and depends neither on the portfolio nor on the number of trades. Plus cannot be booked yet.

Assumptions and limits

Sources

More good to know